First, guncam:
Pros:
-.built-in clipping editor
-Works on battle.net
-Intuitive sound effects
Cons:
-Short demo window
-Minimal online support
I think that in terms of functionality, if the full version of guncam was free I might put it over fraps. But since guncam has a narrow demo window, if you're looking to stay legal and free, fraps has the superior demo since it does not expire--despite the cap it puts on the length of clips. I also like the sound effect it makes when you start/stop recording in guncam, even if it means you have to edit some clips a little more to remove the sound. And it's the only one I know of with a built in .gif maker, even if I never used that feature.
Wegame:
Pros
-Automatic upload of screenshots (for screenshots, Wegame wins because of this. This is just really great)
-'theoretically' easy upload of videos to their server without having to muck with youtube
Cons
-Uploading videos screws up... A LOT
-To join WeGame, you have to sacrifice an e-mail account, because they REQUIRE, as far as I can tell, your e-mail password too. So if you don't have a half dozen empty hotmail accounts sitting around like I do, be prepared to make one.
-WeGame crashes on battle.net
-Video capture with WeGame will often not work with Windows Movie Maker
Ultimately, I decided WeGame was more of a pain than it was really worth. However, the ease of uploading screenshots really is a saving grace that I can honestly say might make it worth it if you find using photobucket or the equivalent as much of a pain as I do.
Fraps:
Pros:
-Works pretty much everywhere always
-Does not expire as far as I know
-Records directly to .avi in the demo
Cons:
-Records only to .avi in the demo
-No online support for video/screenshots
-Cap on length of clip
Since .avi is really the one format that works with everything (windows movie maker/youtube) this generally makes a lot of sense to record to it directly. The only problem is that .avi is BIG, so you need to have a fair amount of space available and be ready to do some cleanup after a run of doing video with it. Also, it was really hard to be bothered to upload screenshots again after using WeGame.
BUT there appears to be a cap for the demo on the length of clips you can record, something like about 30 seconds. It makes it a little jarring, and I suppose that actually is a rather significant handicap. Still better than a "DEMO" tag on clips if you're past your Guncam allotment.
Showing posts with label Fraps. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Fraps. Show all posts
Friday, April 9, 2010
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)